Showing posts with label Thomas Moore. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Thomas Moore. Show all posts

Sunday, 14 December 2025

522. Trillium.

 



  I passed many happy hours, many, many times in Purnell’s. It was luxurious in a Birmingham sort of way. It was both sophisticated and comfortable. It had with it a sense of humour running through it and it was so relaxing. The food of course, at its height, deserved another star.

  But Purnell’s is gone. Glynn Purnell, in his early middle age, has embraced change and the realities of the state of the hospitality business in the mid-2020s under Starmer and Reeves. First there came a country town pub and then a tapas bar and then an ephemeral bistro in Coventry. And now we have a full-on 90 minutes only sittings, bustling wine bar/restaurant in the depths of an always intriguing glass monster in Snowhill. Lots of coloured lights, a very crowded kitchen in the corner of the dining area where you can see quite closely the sweat on the brows of two Michelin-starred chefs working almost elbow to elbow and a clientele of comfortably off quite old lunchers side by side with besuited office men and quite chicly dressed younger women hoping to be noticed and all, like me, photographing their food.

  And there are so many familiar faces working there, some of whom had previously worked for Purnell or for Rob Palmer when he had been Head Chef at Hampton Manor where Peel’s Restaurant won a Michelin star while he was working there or for him when he had his own small Michelin-listed restaurant, Toff’s, in Solihull high street. There were two front of house staff from Simpsons including Thomas Moore who had been, for a few months, the sommelier there and a fine job he had been doing there, There was the former restaurant manager from Kray Tredwell’s 670 Grams and the former restaurant manager of the glitzy Gaucho in Church Street opposite the Grand Hotel. Quite a line up.



  I was the first customer served at 12 noon on the restaurant’s first day of opening. How did its galaxy of Birmingham restaurant figures do in the first 90 minutes of service? Did the food match up to the para-glitz?

  Well, let’s remember that this was the birth of Trillium and some births can be easier than others and I was dining there when the placenta was still waiting to be delivered though the child was giving its first shrieks of being brought into the world. It was a good welcome with Glynn Purnell doing his best to shake everyone’s hands as they arrived. Many of those there at this moment, I suspect were old fans of his and keen to relive their Purnell memories and share with him his vision of Birmingham’s culinary future. At the end of the first hour the place was full and buzzing, the multitude of chefs almost tripping over each other in the small cooking area and food coincidently getting colder than one might have expected. But let’s remember, this was hour one, day one and everything follows the rule that practice makes perfect.




  To start, I chose an eponymous Trillium cocktail - it seemed appropriate to start off with the restaurant’s own. However, for some reason, the Trillium was not available so I chose instead a pleasing Sour though the price seemed a little ambitious. I was beginning to feel I was lunching in London and Trillium reminded me of Fallow where I had dined a couple of Christmases ago prior to seeing another Shakespeare mangling in a West End theatre - bustle, noise, the rapid evaporation of money and middle class rusticity. 











  And so, en fin, to the food. I had a mild gasp when I saw the prices but settled down to see what Purnell and Parmer were going to serve up for that sort of cash. It was recommended that I have a snack to start, a couple of small plates and then a large plate. I broadly followed the guidelines.  Snackwise I opted for Trillium milk loaf, (£7.50) restfully lemon coloured with a tasty soft crust paired with a dip of balsamic vinegar, oil and chicken fat. This was good but in the back of my mind I longed for the halcyon days of Purnell’s pain de campagne with cultured butter.



    I also chose, and enjoyed, a single but large (“XXL”) gougère (on the menu “gougére”). The exterior was enjoyably crispy and the innards molten and full of flavour and, like everything else, not cheap at £6 per gourgère). I failed to photograph it. Then on to the roast Orkney scallop ‘small plate’ - it was well-cooked as one would hope it to be when paying £20 for a single and not enormous scallop and I felt I had had more enjoyable accompaniments with scallops than the not-overwarm dessert spoonful of oxtail Bolognaise ragu that lurked on the shell under the scallop like a diminutive Peeping Tom.



  My ‘large plate’ was grilled Tamworth pork chop (£35) served with salsa verde, olive and manchego. This was a bountiful pork chop, well-cooked but rendered vaguely unpleasant by the bitter salsa verde. This dish may have appealed to those who view themselves as having sophisticated palates which happily embrace bitterness but it did not appeal to me. And the chop was so large that I became bored with it by the time I had eaten half of it and there was nothing to do but to scrape the salsa off it, cut it up and take it back home for Lucy the Labrador who delightedly make short measure of it. The best part of the course was the really rather good gratin of baked potato, crispy skins and chive (the flavour of which was for me completely muted) though the portion was very small and severely overpriced at £6. I felt, on the whole, I could do an equally good job of cooking a pork chop and mashed potato at home, far more interesting than this, at a fraction of the price. 




   After the great lump of pork I wanted a light dessert and opted for zabaglione. This was good, possibly needing to be somewhat more robust with its coffee flavour but the figs were a fine addition and the tiny spiced doughnuts were something of a hit.




  
  All was done. The restaurant was full. The heat was rising. The micro-kitchen was where all the action was while the front of house staff were not looking too hard pressed. When paying the bill I was happy to pay the ‘optional’ service charge but not amused by then being asked if I would like to pay an additional ‘tip’ above and beyond the service charge. No I didn’t like. This is a trick which I think is oozing out of London and before that, I think, the United States. This is not appropriate in Birmingham. 

  Purnell has opted to withdraw from fine dining and to go the small plates/large plates route and to charge a lot of money for relatively simple dishes which appear to be largely unimpressive. Purnell’s strength was always in the ingenuity and humour of the fine, gorgeous-looking dishes that came out of his kitchen. ‘Rustic and expensive’ do not in any way attract me but I’m sure Purnell has an enthusiastic audience of diners ready to eat simply but pay the price for something which should have more flair, more thrill and more culinary ambition to it. Compared with what came before, there seems to be a laziness about it all. Money for old rope you might say. It’s early days (well, the earliest actually) but food needs to come out of the kitchen hot. I don’t think that this concept has any direction at present - is it a wine bar? Is it a restaurant worthy of being included in the Michelin Guide? Is it just a place for cool people to be seen and to draw attention to themselves? Time will tell. But time certainly did tell. My bill came to over £117 which included service (but not an additional tip) and that bought me 90 minutes of service. For that sort of money I expect not to be in a nervous state related to having to eat and drink up before I might be ejected (clearly the staff were far too polite to do that but who knows what will happen when one is sitting there hoping to relax over an expensively decent meal?).

Raring;-🌛🌛.

10 December 2025.


Tuesday, 6 May 2025

480. The Last Sunday Lunch At Simpsons - The Beef Wellington.

 


 The hospitality business being what it is at present, it was announced a short while ago that with bookings not being quite as numerous as they might be, this was to be the last Sunday lunch served at Simpsons - at least for the foreseeable future. And at last I had someone to join me at Sunday lunch there so that I could order the somewhat celebrated Simpsons beef Wellington. And, who knows if Simpsons’ Sunday lunch will ever return given that Andreas Antona has put the business up for sale? The end, or the possible end, of an era. All things must pass …. eventually.



  The Sunday lunch went out in style. Firstly, two familiar amuses gueules - no less delicious for their familiarity - both very toothsome indeed - and this also applied to the equally familiar and equally excellent bread though as always, I would have preferred plain, ordinary salted butter to spread on the breads and this was kindly supplied was requested.



  I had the scallop dish which had been cooked beautifully and served with its beurre blanc sauce in a delightfully retro fashion in a scallop shell. The tender mollusc had a remarkably enjoyable butteriness to it and there was little else that could have been done to improve the dish. There was much apparent simplicity about it and it did not suffer because of this. My companion thoroughly enjoyed her beetroot starter.




  Then came the presentation of the Wellington. It looked magnificent and its service did not disappoint. The beef was accurately cooked inside its surrounding cover of mushroom duxelle and fine pastry. Its companions were a very sensibly sized serving of pomme purée, a dish of happy cauliflower with cheese sauce, stunningly delicious, sweet, tender carrots and confit cabbage and a fine red wine sauce. This was a memorable dish served on a memorable occasion at a memorable restaurant.








    Dessert was not an afterthought. My lunch companion was overwhelmed with pleasure at her excellent passion fruit soufflé and I was impressed, more than I expected (though I should have known better) by the caramelised miso tart served with a splendidly tasty blood orange sorbet. 



  The mignardises - a chocolate cracknell decorated with a pattern of the tiles in Simpsons, powerfully flavoured blackcurrant pate de fruit and gorgeously buttery madeleines - rounded off a first class meal at a first class restaurant. Long may it keep serving such magnificent food to the diners of Birmingha.




Rating:- 🌞🌞🌞.

Monday, 21 April 2025

475. Easter Sunday Lunch At Simpsons.

 



  It was a nice treat to be invited by friends to join them at Simpsons for lunch on Easter Sunday to celebrate the birthday of one of them, And what a glorious spring day it was. The sky was blue, the sun was bright, everyone looked relaxed and full of the spirit of Easter. It was good to see that many of the diners, especially the older ones, were dressed to dine in a smart place where the food was fine and for something a bit special. If the restaurant can make the effort then the diners should too.

  I arrived somewhat earlier than my friends and was warmly greeted, within the parameters that one would expect from such an august establishment, and was soon indulging myself in a white port and tonic and ordering a bottle of Hundred Hills (an Oxfordshire winery east of Didcot) Preamble No 2 which my friends and I were pleased to drink with our canapé’s brought to us in the lounge prior to moving to the main restaurant. I enjoyed the English sparkling wine very much - crisp and refreshing without the strong acidity so often encountered in some of these products.



  The canapés, as always, were delicious - a lovely, crispy cod fritter and a delicious and equally crispy tartlet filled with fine beef tartare and garnished very prettily. A charmingly relaxed way to kick off a meal in good company. Then to the restaurant for the main event.



  There was the usual bread and butter course to start. This sounds all very routine but the bread there is so lovely that there is nothing routine about it. The brioche with duxelle was crispy and the sourdough toothsome and the wild garlic butter on this occasion was pleasingly restrained in flavour.



  We had chosen the three course Sunday lunch which experience told me was quite adequate to fill the stomach on the Sabbath and perhaps stimulate a little snooze (otherwise known in Italian, as my friends told me, to general mirth, as a pisolino, the word learnt from their Italian son-in-law, a scientist with a passion for making the perfect pizza).

  I chose the admirable Chalk Stream trout starter which was meaty though perhaps may have benefitted from a little more punchiness in its flavour. The really stand out ingredients in the dish which somewhat put the fish in the shade were the gorgeously sweet Isle of Wight tomatoes which would have been a very memorable starter in their own right.The basil, seed and olive dressing fully chimed in unison with the heritage tomatoes and much pleasure was derived from them.  One of my fellow dinners chose the scallop dish and found it to be cooked entirely to his liking.



  For my main I chose Blythborough pork (from St Margaret’s Farm, Mells, Halesworth in Suffolk, not all that far away from where my paternal ancestors lived for about 1350 years from about 550 AD to 1984 when they trooped off to Birmingham via a short sojourn in London where they ran a pub). The pork was as tender as butter but for my taste perhaps a little more seasoning might have raised it even higher. The roast potatoes were immaculate and the celeriac gel and apple sauce proved to be nice accompaniments with the vegetables all finely cooked - the hispi cabbage was spot on, the carrots had just the right texture and the cauliflower was also nicely cooked though, as I have previously written, I should love a dish of cauliflower sans cheese sauce just the once to be able to fully relish the full unique flavour of that noble vegetable. Will any chef ever be brave enough to present a dish of cauliflower exalted by being allowed to stand there nude and fully revealed and as bold as brass? 

  My hostess chose the butter poached cod and expressed no regrets.





  My hosts thoroughly enjoyed their passion fruit soufflés which I had experienced previously. Each soufflé that comes out of that kitchen is magnificent to behold and a wonder of Birmingham gastronomy. There was a nice touch when Steve Locklin, the restaurant manager who has been with Simpsons since August 2024, having previously carried out the same role in Lunar in Stoke on Trent when Niall Keating had been Executive Chef there (and where I had previously come across him) and also had been in a senior role at Hoar Cross Hall and before that at Liam Dillon’s The Boat in Lichfield, added an edible ‘Happy Birthday” decoration to the birthday boy’s soufflé. For my dessert I had the chocolate mille feuille which was splendidly crispy with pleasingly unaggressively flavoured chocolate cream.




  The final act - the petit fours - came in the form of an enjoyable chocolate cracknell, an extraordinarily sharp blackcurrant pate de fruit and a lovely little madeleine which was bringer of great joy.



  My host was given a very nice souvenir of his birthday lunch in the form of a birthday card with a picture of the restaurant from the garden and nicely signed by staff members. As a collector of menus and the ilk I couldn’t help feeling just that little it jealous.




Rating:- 🌞🌞🌞.

20 April 2025. 

Thursday, 20 February 2025

462. Sunday Lunch At Simpsons.

 

  After a thrilling and delicious Sunday lunch the previous week at Stirchley’s Eat Vietnam’s collaboration with Dan Lee, I felt I was ready to be a little more sedate and classic at Simpsons which of course has recently been put up for sale by its owner and founder, the doyen of Birmingham and West Midlands dining, Andreas Antona. I had opted for the three course Sunday lunch - I had sirloin pave with Yorkshire pudding on my mind as the alluring beef Wellington was only available for couples to share, misere me.

  Simpsons does very good canapés and those served on this visit were delicious and I ate them alongside a white port and tonic. To be honest, the realisation came to me that I was gobbling them with all the pleasure a little gluttony brings with it. Well, I was sitting in a discrete corner being served, to my great pleasure, by Thomas Moore (not, as far as I know, related to his namesake who so displeased Henry VIII and thereby earned himself a sainthood though it took a few centuries for him to achieve that earthly reward). 

  Thomas had worked at an early stage in his career at the late Purnell’s and had been the chief server at one of my birthday dinners which I liked to hold there every year for close friends to have the opportunity to urge me to run life’s course for another twelve months. Thomas had been very impressive, virtually an infant prodigy in his knowledge and carrying out of his work front-of-house, and had been promoted at Purnell’s and worked there till the restaurant gasped its last breath. By then he was accomplished in the knowledge and service of wines, and as one door closed another opened. As Purnell’s was closing, so Simpsons’ esteemed sommelier, Gian Giancomo Stella, announced he was returning to Italy after seven years in his finely executed role in Edgbaston, and Thomas was appointed to succeed him and work with him as he familiarised himself with the job. 

  I was also pleased to hear about Adrien Garnier who been Restaurant Manager and Sommelier at Purnell’s - he had decided to return to France after Purnell’s closure but had kept in touch with Thomas and during the meal, Thomas texted Adrien to let him know I was dining at Simpsons and Adrien had replied with a message of good wishes. How very charming and kind.



Thomas Moore

Gian Giancomo Stella 
  
Adrien Garnier


The starter proper was a lovely lobster and prawn raviolo - nicely sized and the pasta well made - with tender salsify and robustly flavoured lobster and pepper sauce. This was an excellent dish. I was recently reading some food reviews by Jay Rayner, who eats well like so many metropolitan socialists who enjoy and can afford the good life (Raymond Postgate the founder of the Good Food Guide was also a notable socialist who made sure he ate the best of food), and who is the retiring food critic of The Observer, and a quote from his final missive for the Observer Food Monthly states, “Hyper-expensive foods are never about deliciousness; they are about status. Don’t bother with them”. 

  Well, firstly he does not define at which point ‘expensive’ food becomes ‘hyperexpensive’ food. To a 78 year old pensioner on £13000 per year income who has had their winter fuel allowance grabbed away by the recently elected Starmer Labour government which Rayner enthusiastically endorsed, I suspect that lobster and roast sirloin pavé (at a supplement price of £10 on top of £75 three course meal price) and passion fruit soufflé (further supplement of £10) are all ‘hyper-‘ rather than plain expensive. The champagne socialist may have an alternative definition. Regardless, I believe, that an expensive element which to the people increasingly neglected by the faux socialists now in power, would undoubtedly be ‘hyperexpensive’, lends something to the pleasure of a special meal which is something that one goes to restaurants like Simpsons to enjoy. The lobster was lovely and the sirloin excellent - tender, cooked to exactly my own preference, delicious and generously portioned.

  It’s a rule that one should listen to experts and then remember that they have their own axe to grind. I suppose, in fact I know, that Simpsons’ prices represent wonderfully good value compared with those of the London restaurants wherein Rayner would most often dine. His ‘hyperexpensive’ is not our ‘hyperexpensive’ and though Simpsons’ prices are not cheap, the quality and delightfulness of the dishes Luke Tipping delivers to diners there represents very good value. Long may it continue even after Andreas Antona has sold the business. 

  The slices of sirloin were served with a towering, crispy Yorkshire pudding and the tenderest, most gorgeously cooked and handsome-looking carrots I have been served in many a moon (others no doubt would have liked some bite to their’s but the undercooked carrot people have had their way for far too long and it’s good to see the kitchens of Simpsons leading the fight back). The roast potatoes again were the mostly accurately, perfectly cooked I have been served in recent memory and I enjoyed the shredded cabbage. The weakest element was the cauliflower with cheese sauce which needed more of the sauce, given that sauce was served, to give it more cheesy flavour though I wish there would be some restaurant or the other which would  serve the cauliflower denuded of any such covering so that diners could appreciate the flavour of cauliflower in all its unique naked flavour. The beef sauce was unctuous and delicious but I should have liked more heat in my horseradish sauce.








  Finally the dessert. I was not able to resist the prospect of the passion fruit soufflé though I longed almost equally to have my first rhubarb of the year which was one of the alternatives. The soufflé was impeccable and the ‘exotic sauce’ was dominated by mango and the chantilly cream innocuous though not really necessary. At the bottom of the dish, when the soufflé had all been scooped away, there was a distinct and not very pleasant bitterness from the sauce that lurked there which I think might have some alcohol element though I could not tell as I disliked it enough not to consume it. This was a pity but it did not ruin what had been a fine meal of a very high standard. I rounded off the meal with a post prandial After Eight cocktail and two delightful mignardises - a delightfully chewy macaron and a Madeleine which was the stuff that dreams are made on and I felt rather pleased with myself. Simpsons marches on. The doyen is still the doyen. 

Rating:-🌞🌞🌞.

16 February 2026.